Blog Series · Is it woke?
Is The Wire (2002) Woke? chudrank Score and Reception
- Type
- TV series
- Released
- 2002
- Genre
- Crime, Drama
Is The Wire (2002) woke? Above is its live chudrank score; below, the facts, why it scores the way it does, and what critics said. Disagree? Every vote moves the score.
What it is
The Wire is an American crime drama television series created and primarily written by American author and former police reporter David Simon for the cable network HBO.
Wikipedia, The Wire, quoted verbatim · CC BY-SA 4.0
Why it reads WOKE
Creator David Simon made The Wire an attack on the drug war, failing institutions and unchecked capitalism, and critics praised it for showing race and poverty in Baltimore. Barack Obama calls it his favourite show, and a National Review writer says the left loved it.
Simon called the second season "a deliberate argument that unencumbered capitalism is not a substitute for social policy". (Wikipedia)
Tim Goodman of the San Francisco Chronicle wrote that The Wire "has tackled the drug war in this country as it simultaneously explores race, poverty and 'the death of the American working class,' the failure of political systems to help the people they serve". (Wikipedia)
Former President of the United States Barack Obama has said that The Wire is his favorite television series. (Wikipedia)
National Review's Jonah Goldberg calls Simon "pretty much a member of the Naomi Klein/Noam Chomskyite school of leftism" and adds: "The Left loved the show." (National Review)
Why it is not further WOKE
Some on the right love it too. Goldberg argues the city it shows is run by Democrats, so its real target is urban liberalism. When a viewer called it conservative art, Simon pushed back: the show could back police work against violent crime and still attack the drug war, because two things can be true at once.
Goldberg: "the show itself strikes a target much closer to home: blue-state urban liberalism." (National Review)
TheWrap reports Simon bristled after the show was called "the best piece of conservative art ever made" and "seemed to suggest the show could in the same vein represent police in a positive light as it related to the fight against violent crime and homicide while also highlighting the wasted resources they inhabit in the wider 'war on drugs.'" (TheWrap)
Simon's reply, quoted by TheWrap: "Two things can be true at once and in this case are." (TheWrap)
So: a left-wing creator's attack on the drug war and capitalism, which conservatives also claim as an indictment of liberal city government. Disagree? Vote, and the score moves.
What critics said
All seasons of The Wire have received positive reviews from major television critics, with seasons two through five in particular receiving near universal acclaim, with several naming it the best contemporary show and one of the best drama series of all time. The first season received mainly positive reviews from critics, some even calling it superior to HBO's better-known "flagship" drama series such as The Sopranos and Six Feet Under.
Wikipedia, The Wire, quoted verbatim · CC BY-SA 4.0